The Hangman was Robert Taylor’s first independent film after leaving MGM. In later years, he would describe it as one of his failures. Like many Taylor movies, it’s an unusual twist on a familiar subject. Mackenzie Bovard, a Deputy Marshal, is famous for his ability to catch criminals who are later hanged. Bovard is cynical and world weary with a poor opinion of his fellow humans. Pursuing a robbery suspect, he meets the young and lovely Tina Louise. Through his relationship with her Bovard gradually regains his faith in humanity and becomes a much warmer and more likeable person. This is far from a typical western–no fight scenes, no gorgeous scenery, no evil villains. As another reviewer noted, it’s a drama set in the old West. It’s about responsibility, right and wrong and personal development and growth. Taylor is excellent, as always, in his understated way. Tina Louise is good as a young woman who changes from a drab loser to a confident woman. Mabel Albertson is wonderful as a middle-aged woman who has the hots for Taylor (who can blame her?). Fess Parker, post Davy Crockett is effective as a town Sheriff and his laid back persona makes a good contrast to the driven, more intense Taylor. Perhaps not a classic but definitely worth watching and owning.
I don’t know why Mr. Taylor disliked the film so much. Perhaps he was uncomfortable working outside of MGM. The film has humor, romance, a moral and some good acting. Robert Taylor wasn’t as well photographed as he was at MGM. Since he was never specific about his dislike, it will be one of many mysteries he left behind.
Frame grabs:
The young woman is Tina Louise, pre Gilligan’s Island.
Promotional materials:
With Fess Parker and Tina Louise.
On the set:
A light moment with Tina Louise.
Robert Taylor Actor 
thanks for your review, Judith! I enjoy atypical Westerns but I haven’t watched The Hangman yet. I like the pictures you post very much!
LikeLike
Thanks, Kendra. It’s available on DVD in the US.
LikeLike
A pretty accurate description Judith. It was a low key release here and cannot recall it being played on cable and in fact I had only seen the once in a theatre many years ago. However, when I was visiting your country 2 years ago to go with my friend Janie, to the 100th Year Birthday Celebration, I ordered a copy from a US online store and it is now part of my RT collection. I really enjoyed it although I thought Robert Taylor acted a bit more sombre than the part required, nevertheless an interesting film with each character revealing layers in their personality as the film progressed.
LikeLike
You’re right. Our first impressions of the characters are not our final ones. The first time I saw it I was really surprised that Tina Louise chose Mr. Taylor over the younger Fess Parker. But I applaud her good taste.
LikeLike
Thanks for sharing. I would love to watch it, but I don’t know where it will be showing. Any info on that? -another fanatic person about Robert Taylor, the late great
LikeLike
It is available on DVD from Warner Archive in the US. There are also copies for sale on Amazon. Thanks for the comment.
LikeLike
Hi Judith,
I really like this movie. Did u see the flub up of the crew member who jumped into the scene and jumped back out during Jack Lord break out of jail and getting on the horse… You can see the man in white shirt and slacks off in the distance.
Becky
LikeLike
Hi, Becky, no I never noticed the crew member. Apparently the film editors didn’t, either. I do like this movie. The business of Mr. Taylor being handcuffed to Tina Louise is really funny. Judith
LikeLike