Robert Taylor appeared on the television program “What’s My Line” on February 26, 1956. John Daly was (as always) the host and the panelists were Arlene Francis, Dorothy Kilgallen, Bennett Cerf and Fred Allen. When he signed in there was a huge burst of applause and cheering.
Robert Taylor appeared uneasy as he sat down next to John Daly. He answered the first question about being a film actor in a high voice which got laughs. Mr. Taylor made good use of his eyebrows during the next couple of questions. Pretty soon he was asked if he had shared billing lately with with a buffalo, which gave away the game. More applauding and cheering from the audience. Earlier on the same show, a buffalo handler (I believe) from “The Last Hunt” had appeared and the producers thought the panelists would be thrown off and not expect someone else from the film.
Bennett Cerf recounted meeting Jane Russell earlier in the day and asking her whether she would be appearing on “What’s My Line?” She denied it and he found her denial “rather false.” One of the women, probably Ms. Kilgallen, commented that “that’s the only thing about her that is,” referring to Ms. Russell’s famous upper body development. Everyone broke up at that point. Fred Allen made a buffalo joke.
John Daly then recounted seeing “The Last Hunt” in Nassau before it opened in New York. Daly said he enjoyed the film but that Taylor’s character had been a mean man. Mr. Taylor agreed, calling the character of Charlie Gilson “a real meanie.”
Finally Bennett Cerf asked whether it was true that the entire production company of “The Last Hunt” had returned from Hollywood to North Dakota for one retake. Mr. Taylor said they hadn’t.
Daly then thanked Mr. Taylor for appearing and Mr. Taylor jumped up and left with alacrity. Throughout the program he had rubbed his face nervously. The whole appearance lasted for 3 minutes 32 seconds. Robert Taylor did whatever was needed to publicize a film, but this didn’t seem to be a favorite venue for him.